Chairy Situation

In the last year, I've had 3 different chairs in the same spot in the living room.  Like a crazy person, I keep purchasing chairs and swapping them out at least once every couple of months.  Cannot decide which one I like more!??

 I originally started off with an Ikea Poang chair, which now sits in my boyfriend's living room.  I swapped that out for this red Lunna Chair which I kept for a couple of years.

 Earlier this year I swapped out the Lunna for this rattan chair that I got on Craigslist for $20.  I went to Pier1 and picked up the cushion on clearance for $15, but I'm not totally in love with this look, but I am totally digging the armrests.

I spotted this beauty on Craigslist.  Initially they were sold at Ikea and I had wanted the orange one, but at $400 they were a bit out of my price range and they discontinued that color this year...so I was pretty happy to get this, and for way less than half of the price of a new one.  While carrying this monstrosity into my apartment, I accidentally dropped it on my foot....REALLY HARD and let me tell you...it hurt like HELL!  My toes are totally black and blue and look horrible, but surprisingly I feel no pain now.

So....right now I still have all three chairs, but I'm not sure which one works best in this space.  What I really need to do is go into therapy for my Craigslist addiction problem!